Ready or Not 2: Here I Come Blu-ray Review: Buy It for Samara Weaving

The original Ready or Not ended exactly the way it needed to. Grace standing in the smoking wreckage, covered in blood, finally free, and then the credits roll before you can breathe. It is one of the cleanest endings in modern horror comedy. I have recommended that film to everyone I know who will sit still long enough to watch it, and I will keep doing that until I run out of people.

That ending is also the reason every sequel to a film like that walks into a wall before it even starts. You cannot top it. You can only try to justify the next chapter. The question with Ready or Not 2: Here I Come is not whether it is as good as the first film. It is not. The question is whether it earns its own place in the room.

The Game Gets Bigger. Messier. Longer.

Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett pick up exactly where they left off. Grace is still reeling. She is also, almost immediately, back in a game she never asked to play. This time with her estranged sister Kathryn Newton at her side and four rival families hunting them both for the High Seat of the Council. The stakes are bigger, the mythology is expanded, and the body count climbs accordingly.

What the duo does well, they have always done well. They understand that the engine of this kind of film is tension, and that tension and comedy run on the same fuel. Bettinelli-Olpin has said that the goal was always for the audience to not know where a scene is going, whether it is about to be emotional, scary, funny, or all three at once. That instinct is alive and working in the best stretches of this film. There are sequences here that are genuinely, painfully funny in the way the first film was funny, dark and mean.

The problem is the size of it. This film is roughly twenty minutes longer than it needs to be and the extra weight shows in the second half. The first Ready or Not worked in part because it was tight. One house. One night, one terrible house rule. Here I Come stretches the mythology outward and some of it holds and some of it does not. By the time the finale arrives, a few of the threads the film introduced have been quietly abandoned. This is a film that wanted to say more than it had time to finish saying.

It is still fun. I want to be clear about that. It is loud and bloody, and it commits to its own absurdity with the confidence of a film that knows what it is. That counts for something. I just wanted a little more of what the first one was.

You Cast Sarah Michelle Gellar. You Use Her.

Sarah Michelle Gellar is in this movie. She plays Ursula Danforth, a member of the rival coalition hunting Grace down. It is a role with real potential, the right kind of villain for a film like this, the kind that should crackle with energy every time she is on screen.

It does not crackle. This is not Gellar’s fault. She does what the script gives her, and she does it with commitment, but what the script gives her is not enough. You do not cast Sarah Michelle Gellar in a horror comedy and then leave her at the edges of it. Her whole career has been about anchoring exactly this kind of material.

Buffy exists because of what she does with a role like this. The fact that Here I Come does not fully deploy that resource is probably the most frustrating thing about the film. Someone in a future project is going to cast her correctly and the rest of us are going to feel it.

Samara Weaving Is Holding This Together

There is one non-negotiable reason to watch this film and her name is Samara Weaving.

She is carrying this movie. Not in the way that lead actors carry a film by anchoring the narrative, she is doing that too, but in the specific way of a performer who refuses to let the material drop below the level her commitment sets. Every scene she is in has a floor. Nothing sags when she is present because she will not let it. Watch how the other actors respond to her in the scenes they share. They step up. She does that to a room.

Her scream in this film is the best single moment in either movie. I will not tell you where it lands or what triggers it. You will know it when you hear it. It does not sound like acting. There is something genuinely dark buried inside of Samara Weaving that the camera catches when she is not thinking about it, something that lives right at the surface of Grace and occasionally breaks through completely. She is the best final girl of this generation and I do not believe that is a close call. Not Jennifer, not Sydney, not any of them. Weaving.

Whatever is living underneath that performance, she keeps it just barely in check. God help the franchise that finally lets it out completely.

Most disc releases give you one commentary track if you are lucky, and it is usually the director talking over their own film for an hour and a half in a way that confirms they made all the choices they made. Here I Come gives you two, and they are genuinely different products.

The first pairs Bettinelli-Olpin and Gillett with Weaving and Newton, the talent track, the one that gives you the room energy of the production. The second is the craft track: directors, writers Guy Busick and R. Christopher Murphy, producers James Vanderbilt and Tripp Vinson, and editor Jay Prychidny sitting down to walk through how the film was actually built. Those are two different experiences and both of them are worth your time.

Ready or Not 2: Here I Come is now on digital via Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, and Fandango at Home. Blu-ray and DVD arrive on June 16 from Searchlight Pictures. It is a bigger, messier, slightly overstuffed version of the first film, and it is still fun, and Samara Weaving is still the best in the business at this. The bonuses make this one worth owning. Buy it for her. Stay for the extras.

About the Release

Ready or Not 2: Here I Come is directed by Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett (Radio Silence) and written by Guy Busick and R. Christopher Murphy. The film stars Samara Weaving, Kathryn Newton, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Shawn Hatosy, Nestor Carbonell, David Cronenberg, and Elijah Wood. Distributed by Searchlight Pictures. Verified Hot on Rotten Tomatoes with a 90% Popcornmeter score.

The Game Goes On: The Making of Ready or Not 2 (4-part featurette) — Part 1: Written in Blood / Part 2: Casting the Chaos / Part 3: Designed for Destruction / Part 4: Blood, Guts, and Practical Mayhem. Rules of the Game. Gag Reel. Audio Commentary by the directors with Samara Weaving and Kathryn Newton. Audio Commentary by the directors with writers Guy Busick and R. Christopher Murphy, producers James Vanderbilt and Tripp Vinson, and editor Jay Prychidny.

Available now on digital. Blu-ray and DVD June 16 from Searchlight Pictures.