Michelle’s Death, Alex MacNicoll and Spence Moore II’s Exits, Sarah Steele’s Debut Explained

[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for Brilliant Minds Season 2 Episode 11 “The Boy Who Feels Everything.”]

Brilliant Minds‘ midseason return on Monday, January 5, is a devastating one. Not only does one character die, but it also looks like the last episode for two of Wolf’s (Zachary Quinto) fellows.

Following the fall finale car crash, Van’s (Alex MacNicoll) girlfriend, Michelle (Stacey Farber), is brain dead, and he struggles to accept it throughout this episode — to the point that he and the other fellows take her in an ambulance to bring her to a hospital in New Jersey where there’s a religious exemption for brain death. But along the way, he imagines her waking up and the life they could have had together, including a wedding, and that’s how he accepts that there’s nothing that can be done. After, Van decides he needs to step away from work to be there for their son, and then Jacob (Spence Moore II) reveals he is leaving for that position at a sports clinic in Dallas.

Then, to end the episode, Wolf returns to his father’s apartment, and to his surprise, it’s not Noah (Mandy Patinkin) who walks in, but Sofia, a new character played by Sarah Steele. She knows that he knows Noah and that they’d meet sooner or later — and she calls him by name when remarking that Wolf looks just like him.

Below, showrunner Michael Grassi explains why Michelle died, reveals if that was Alex MacNicoll and Spence Moore II’s last episode, teases Sarah Steele’s character, and more.

Why kill off Michelle and did you ever consider not?

Michael Grassi: So last season and even the first week of the room this season, we wanted to tell a story about brain death and how complex it is. You have somebody who’s in front of you who still has a pulse, they’re warm, they look like the person you love, and they’re dead and accepting that is so hard. And while it is something that is medically absolute, it does not mean that it makes it easy or simple for a family or a loved one processing this. And we talked about various ways in which we wanted to tell this story, but the thing we kept on coming back to is the most impactful way to tell this story is with one of our very own losing somebody that they love. That’s the only way we will be able to capture the emotional gravity of having to process something like this, especially someone that we love with Van and we’ve been invested in his relationship with Michelle and how complex it is and complicated is, and they have a kid and all of those really messy things that make this even harder. So we wanted to be grounded and tell the truthful version of this that felt direct and not shy away from a difficult topic. And that’s why we chose to go this way with Michelle.

Pief Weyman/NBC

Speaking of making it harder, that what could have been montage was absolutely heartbreaking. Why include that?

That to me is — I think about the episode as Van as our A patient in a weird way. And I think that moment really is Van’s patient POV. We’re starting to process with him. He’s starting to imagine what his life — he’s basically bargaining. He’s trying to hold onto her longer and through holding onto her this long and seeing how far he’s going in an ambulance with his friends and imagining that she’s coming back to life and imagining that they’re getting married, in that extreme, he’s finally able to accept. So that’s what that sequence is. Basically we’re getting into Van’s patient POV and understanding that how hard this decision is.

I wrote down bargaining and acceptance in my notes during that part of it.

I know you did. I have no doubt. [Laughs]

Was this Spence and Alex’s last episode? Because the way it ended with them felt like exits in a way.

Well, this is what I’ll say. I love Spence and I love Alex. They’ve been with the show from the very beginning, and I’m huge fans of theirs, and they are still very much a part of our world. And in that last scene, Wolf says something that he means, he says, “My door is always open.” So my hope is that this is not the last we will see of Van and Jacob on Brilliant Minds.

But for now it is? We’re not going to see them in the next few episodes?

No, no. But they’re still a part of our world. We’ll definitely hear about them and hopefully hear from them. And my hope in my prayer is that we’ll see them soon.

Sarah Steele, her introduction at the end. I am so intrigued by Sofia. Who is she to Noah and to Oliver?

First of all, I can’t say that, but good question. And I also have to say I love Sarah Steele. I’m a huge Sarah Steele fan, and I’m so happy she’s on Brilliant Minds. She is always excellent, but she’s doing some incredible work on Brilliant Minds and we are going to — I can say one thing, OK, and I will say that her relationship and her connection with Noah is not what we expect and is going to be surprising to Wolf as well.

According to her character description, she’s suffering from a medical mystery that Wolf struggles to crack. Could it be that Noah’s symptoms were actually hers and he left because she didn’t want to keep lying to his son?

I’m not going to answer that.

This medical mystery, is Wolf approaching it in a similar way? Because it’s a similar conundrum for him as the beginning of the season was with Noah’s.

Here is what I’ll say: You know how we’ve done serialized patients. She is a new serialized patient that we’re meeting at the end of 11. And stay tuned.

Is it just as puzzling though for Oliver, like this medical mystery as Noah’s was, whereas he’s not finding answers right away? Can you say that?

Yeah, I think so. And I think that there’s an unexpected sort of connection between the two that’s built is something that I can add.

What does Wolf think of her in that moment when she walks in and with what she says to him? Who’s he thinking that she is?

When he’s sitting at that desk at his dad’s desk and he hears someone come in, I think he’s like, my dad’s about to walk through that door. So when she walks in, he’s basically in his mind is like, “Don’t call the police. I know him.” He is scared for a second and I think he has no idea what to think or what to expect. That develops.

What can you say about whether we’ll see Mandy Patinkin again this season?

I can neither confirm nor deny.

What can you say about the next time that Wolf and Amelia (Bellamy Young) cross paths in the present?

What I’ll say to that is the Amelia story and Wolf and Amelia comes to a head and it’s coming sooner and in a more surprising way than we expect sooner rather than later.

Brilliant Minds, Mondays, 10/9c, NBC