Jimmy Butler Struggles Continue As Golden State Warriors Fall To Minnesota Timberwolves

The “Playoff Jimmy” label from Butler got yet another dent last night, as the Heat star was quite quiet and off-the-mark from the field, with 17 points, scoring 4 of 11 in the loss at the hands of the Minnesota Timberwolves.

Advertisement

Sports analyst Kevin O’Connor posted the numbers: “Butler is averaging only 21 points inefficiently in the last 11 elimination games.” The Heat have lost eight times in such instances, plus winning thrice whenever the stakes were carved on his favor; Butler’s last genuinely stomping playoff moment was more than two years ago against the Bucks.

Some very divided reactions followed O’Connor’s tweet about Butler’s legacy: Some defended him, while others tarnished him. SalemHawatmeh18 came to his defense: “Nah man, this guy railed the number one seeded Bucks. I will never forget that performance. One of the greatest I have ever seen in a single series.” They were referring to the 2022 playoffs when he led the underdog Heat all the way to the Eastern Conference Finals.

Others weren’t so forgiving. Neil Simpson lashed out at Butler for passivity: ‘This level of passiveness is f**king embarrassing for a dude about to make 60M. Left his team out to dry.’ Some comments referenced Butler’s age, with Swagavelli stating, ‘He’s 35. Everyone is not Bron, KD, or Curry. Jimmy’s Time came and Went.’

Then the injury debate ensued in the replies. AustinRocc pointed to what appeared to hamper Butler: ‘He played injured on one ass cheek. Could easily tell he had no burst or lift.’ BDK2424 then responded: ‘Even in 2023 he was extremely overrated,’ i.e., they’re always making excuses for Butler when he folds in the playoffs.

An equally intriguing view came from wiseoldowl1951: ‘That’s why Riley did not want to give him an additional year at 50 million.’ The Heat reportedly balked at extending Butler’s max contract this offseason, and last night’s performance could very well give credence to that.

Erratic playoff runs have put Butler in basketball purgatory-too much accomplished to be just ignored and yet so flagrantly inconsistent that he can’t be counted among the true playoff greats. The Bucks series in 2022 showed a glimpse of the ceiling of his potential; in stark contrast, the recent antics show the limits. At 35, the window for Playoff Jimmy actually to maintain the defining of his legacy may be closing rather quickly.

Advertisement

A worse loss in the first round throws a somewhat uncertain offseason ahead for the Warriors, whilst Butler and Heat have to think about the possibilities whether the aging star still has enough in him to build around. All that can be safely said is that his days of carrying any team single-handedly deep into the playoffs are far behind him.